Even if Chastity activates for a physical attack, a creature that also has secret ingredient will still lose 1 HP.
Also, not sure if this is intended, but the Shell buff disappears even if Chastity triggers.
And Shell doesn’t even trigger with Secret Ingredient, the first attack does 1 damage even if you have Shell.
All of this is still happening.
Looks like this is working fine now, except for Shell going away even if Chastity activates.