New punishment - 50-50 chance for scorn/silence at start of battle

See above - 50-50 chance for your creatures to be afflicted with scorn/silence at the start of battle. Would force you to change strategy battle to battle.

This punishment should override any debuff protection, etc.

The way I see it - should afflict all your creatures the same way - either all silence or all scorn.

Bonus: More exp, resources, energy, etc.